Energy poverty measures also classify affluent households as poor
BDI Paper

Energy poverty measures also classify affluent households as poor

Common energy poverty indicators also capture affluent households, Bank of Italy research finds, while m-LIHC concentrates on poorer groups. The preferred measure identified over 2.4 million Italian households, or 9.1 percent, as energy poor in 2024.

A filter for genuine deprivation

Bank of Italy and Italian National Institute of Statistics (Istat) researchers propose adopting modified Low Income High Cost (m-LIHC) in official Italian statistics.

It identifies households whose energy spending share exceeds twice the national average and whose remaining expenditure falls below Istat's relative poverty threshold.

It also includes households with below-median equivalent expenditure and no heating expenditure.

Around 70 percent of those identified fall in the bottom two consumption deciles; none are above the median.

Subjective indicators and the 10 percent spending rule also capture affluent households.

The Household Budget Survey supports annual m-LIHC estimates from 2014 without additional costs.

Bill discounts reach too few

Simulations put energy poverty at 7.7 percent with social bonuses versus 8.6 percent without them in 2022, and 9.0 versus 9.5 percent in 2023.

Estimated bonuses total €3.8 billion and €1.7 billion respectively, below actual payments of €4.4 billion and €2.4 billion.

In 2024, fewer than one-fifth of energy-poor households received the electricity bonus.

The authors seek fuller consumption data from Acquirente Unico: existing survey links cover only the free market and cannot match every household uniquely to a meter.

Count households and unmet needs

The authors favor m-LIHC for identifying economically vulnerable households rather than relying on reported heating difficulties alone.

They also acknowledge that expenditure cannot fully reveal unmet energy needs.

Physical consumption and building-efficiency data remain necessary to measure deprivation more fully.

Report an error