Dual-use controls cut exports temporarily but redirect trade
Italian exports of newly controlled dual-use products fall 10–20 percent in the first three quarters after listing, Bank of Italy research using 2017–2023 data finds. Aggregate values recover, but trade moves permanently toward trusted partners.
Recovery conceals lost trade routes
Lilia Patrignani and Michele Savini Zangrandi find no statistically discernible lasting reduction in aggregate exports following EU dual-use listing.
The initial decline is concentrated in machinery and electrical equipment, particularly sales to destinations without simplified licensing.
Exports along established routes fall 34 percent on average and remain depressed over the post-listing window.
Firms compensate by opening trade relationships: listing raises the probability of exporting by 2.2 percentage points, or 24 percent relative to the pre-treatment mean.
Trusted partners' share of export value rises around 8 percentage points, from about 46 to 54 percent.
The United States accounts for a 4.2-percentage-point increase; Turkey also gains.
Screening reaches beyond licensed goods
The Bank of Italy paper uses staggered difference-in-differences estimates covering 192 newly listed products, 180,000 firms and 114 million observations in 2017–2023.
Matching and reweighting checks preserve its main findings.
Dual-use-related goods represented nearly 30 percent of Italy's extra-EU exports in 2021–2023 and involved 106,000 exporters.
Screening extends beyond goods ultimately requiring licenses: licensed dual-use trade accounts for only 2 percent of total EU exports outside the bloc.
General authorizations ease licensing for trusted destinations.
Recovery does not measure security
Aggregate recovery does not establish whether controls achieve their security objectives, which the paper does not evaluate.
The authors identify compliance capacity and licensing efficiency as ways to contain trade costs.
Their estimates exclude software and technology transfers, limiting coverage of the economic burden.
IN: