Remote-work bonuses raise judges' case completions by 16 percent
Remote-work incentives raised participating Italian judges' case completions by 16 percent between September 2025 and June 2026, Enrico Miglino finds in Bank of Italy research. Target courts' backlogs fell by an estimated 5 percent over the ten-month scheme.
Bonuses move cases across courts
Enrico Miglino analyzes 9.5 million civil proceedings from January 2016 to June 2026 using judge mobility and an event-study design.
Italy's scheme attracted 212 judges against a ceiling of 500 to support 48 congested courts.
Completing 50 judgments remotely earned €15,274 plus seniority credits; participants retained their home-court duties.
Monthly completions rose by 3.7 cases, while home-court completions fell by 2.9. Complexity-weighted productivity increased by 30 percent.
Target courts' completions rose by 9 percent, or 19 percent after complexity weighting, alongside extraordinary case-reallocation powers for court presidents.
The author estimates that remote assistance reduced target backlogs by 5 percent and disposition times by 6 percent within ten months.
Relocation carries an output cost
Judges explain 60 percent of productivity variation, compared with 11 percent for courts.
Each physical transfer costs an estimated 237 forgone proceedings, equivalent to five months of output.
Delivering comparable capacity remotely cost an estimated €4.3 million, against €6.9 million for transfers or €7.8 million for workforce expansion.
The scheme's estimated cost per net additional standard-equivalent proceeding was €244, versus €312 through hiring.
The study finds no negative productivity spillovers on non-participating judges.
Short-run gains, unresolved limits
Miglino limits the cost comparison to short-run adjudication because remote judges received cases already through fact-finding.
Only 212 judges participated, and they were already more productive than peers.
Appeal data for incentivized decisions are unavailable, leaving the scheme's effect on decision quality untested.