Poor-country growth advantage survives convergence-model biases
BIS Paper

Poor-country growth advantage survives convergence-model biases

Poorer countries' growth advantage survives objections to standard convergence estimates, Giovanni Lombardo finds in Bank for International Settlements (BIS) research. The evidence identifies a changing income–growth relationship, not a precise catch-up speed.

A break rather than a trend

Lombardo separates within-country adjustment from between-country income–growth gradients using a correlated-random-effects model.

The main estimates cover 164 countries and six non-overlapping decades over 1963–2023, using Penn World Table 11.0. The between-country gradient falls from 1.421 in 1963–73 to 0.121 in 2003–13 and remains low at 0.214 in 2013–23. Tests reject a linear trend but not a single break in 2003–13. A constant-steady-state simulation produces a decline of only 0.12 against 1.30 observed; a simulation incorporating heterogeneous trends produces a rise instead.

The paper attributes the pattern to poorer countries increasingly carrying deeper shortfalls from their own moving steady states.

Catch-up speed remains unidentified

Short-panel bias prevents the within-country coefficient from identifying adjustment speed; observing the same calendar span more frequently does not eliminate it.

A separate regression yields a one-sided 95 percent lower bound of 0.66 percent annual adjustment.

That bound assumes omitted steady-state determinants stand higher in richer countries.

The result bridges Kremer, Willis and You's evidence of changing growth patterns with Acemoglu and Molina's and Pesaran and Smith's objections to interpreting regression coefficients as convergence rates.

Faster growth is not equality

The growth gradient does not establish a narrowing income distribution.

The unweighted standard deviation of log income rises from 0.98 in 1963 to 1.24 in 2023.

Correlations of income ranks across consecutive decade observations never fall below 0.96, despite poorer countries' growth advantage.

Report an error