Motor insurance quotes vary by around €300 for identical profiles
CBI News

Motor insurance quotes vary by around €300 for identical profiles

Comparing motor insurance quotes can save around €300, Central Bank of Ireland research based on June 2026 quotations shows. Consumers also need to compare policy features to ensure equivalent cover.

Same driver, different prices

The Central Bank of Ireland found potential savings of around €300 when comparing motor insurance quotes for identical drivers and vehicles.

Its analysis covered online new business quotes from eight primary insurers for 16 standardised consumer profiles in June 2026.

Prices differed across insurers for every profile.

Online quotes were not always available for higher-risk consumers, including drivers with limited experience, penalty points or business use of their vehicle.

The bank said these consumers could explore brokers or contact insurers directly.

Insurers assess factors relating to the driver, vehicle and cover, consistently differentiating between lower- and higher-risk customers.

Compare cover before switching

Director of Insurance Seána Cunningham said price differences arise even for the same driver and vehicle, with comparison particularly beneficial for consumers receiving very high quotes.

She also urged consumers to compare the level and type of cover, not just the premium.

The bank's guide encourages an annual search for quotes.

It lists safe driving, annual payment, reviewing excess levels and cover, and using available discounts as practical ways to reduce premiums.

Price is not everything

The research distinguishes lower premiums from equivalent protection: policy features also need comparison.

Its evidence covers online new business quotes, not every route to obtaining cover.

For higher-risk drivers, the bank points to brokers and direct insurer contact.

Report an error