Makhlouf backs openness over protection in industrial policy
CBI Speech

Makhlouf backs openness over protection in industrial policy

Central Bank of Ireland Governor Gabriel Makhlouf urged Europe to favor innovation and openness over protected national champions. At a joint research workshop, he backed deeper capital markets, education and infrastructure investment.

Europe's productivity gap drives debate

Makhlouf said industrial policy has a mixed record: targeted support can build capabilities but also protect incumbents, favor politically connected firms and burden public finances.

US annual labor productivity growth fell from 2.7 percent in 1995–2007 to 1.3 percent in 2007–2019; larger European economies slowed from 1.3 to 0.5 percent.

Research and development spending is around 3.5 percent of GDP in the US versus 2.2 percent in Europe.

Citing the Draghi and Letta reports, he linked Europe's difficulties to weaker innovation investment, barriers to scaling firms and fragmented, bank-dependent capital markets.

Deeper capital markets could mobilize almost €12 trillion in European savings and cash deposits for productive investment, he said.

Ireland's gains followed greater openness

Ireland's high tariffs and foreign-ownership restrictions from the 1930s to the 1950s coincided with weak growth, unemployment and emigration.

Greater openness began in the late 1950s, followed by European Economic Community membership in 1973.

Makhlouf linked subsequent gains to trade, foreign investment, education and skills.

Multinationals now employ around a quarter of the workforce.

He also cited Ireland's Industrial Development Agency and urged infrastructure delivery to attract private investment.

Foundations rather than favored champions

Makhlouf's case puts enabling conditions ahead of subsidies for selected firms.

He sees stronger evidence for deeper European markets than for many promoted industrial policies.

His test is whether state action corrects market failures and complements private investment without sacrificing openness.

Report an error