Targeted transfers double welfare gains from VAT relief
BDE Paper

Targeted transfers double welfare gains from VAT relief

Targeted transfers deliver twice the welfare gains of food and energy VAT cuts at the same fiscal cost in a Bank of Spain model of the 2021–2023 inflation episode. Transfers favor lower-income households and borrowers; VAT relief favors retirees and savers.

Equal budgets, unequal protection

Myroslav Pidkuyko and Raffaele Rossi compare Spain's VAT relief with a temporary means-tested transfer expansion in Bank of Spain Working Paper 2642. Fiscal costs match period by period.

Estimated aggregate welfare losses fall from 6.65 percent in consumption-equivalent terms without discretionary support to 6.41 percent with VAT cuts and 6.17 percent with transfers.

Gains are therefore 0.24 and 0.48 percentage points, respectively.

VAT relief raises borrowers' losses from 2.37 to 2.60 percent by reducing inflation-induced debt erosion; transfers lower them to 2.00 percent.

For the bottom income quartile, transfers reduce losses from 6.51 to 5.42 percent.

VAT relief instead concentrates gains among retirees and savers.

Prices explain only part

The partial-equilibrium life-cycle model uses Spanish household expenditure, income and balance-sheet surveys.

Households adjust savings, spending composition and female employment, while price and nominal-income paths are imposed externally.

The sequential decomposition attributes 0.30 percentage points of baseline welfare losses to relative prices, 1.94 to real-income erosion, 2.02 to nominal asset revaluation and 2.39 to fiscal drag.

Transfers support disposable resources directly; VAT cuts mainly reduce necessity prices and protect nominal savings.

Welfare, not just inflation

The authors find that lower inflation alone does not identify the strongest household protection.

The comparison assumes full VAT pass-through and does not model how transfers affect price formation.

Allowing real wages to recover fully by 2028 lowers losses but preserves the policy ranking.

Report an error