Gravelle says oil-price risk materialized as scenarios warned
Bank of Canada Deputy Governor Toni Gravelle said oil prices and inflation tracked an adverse scenario more closely than the baseline. Speaking to the Edmonton Chamber of Commerce, he stressed that policy guidance remains conditional.
Oil tests the baseline
Gravelle said the Bank of Canada (BoC) is publishing scenarios more often to explain uncertainty and potential policy responses.
In April 2026, about two months into the Middle East war, oil cost around $100 per barrel.
The baseline assumed a decline to around $75 by mid-2027, returning inflation to 2 percent in early 2027.
An alternative kept inflation near 3 percent for more than a year and required consecutive policy rate increases.
By October, oil remained near $100, refinery margins exceeded historical norms and inflation had tracked the alternative more closely.
New US tariffs added uncertainty, but the economy exceeded expectations.
Gravelle said the upside inflation risk had largely materialized; he did not present the scenario as an unconditional policy commitment.
Guidance without a promise
Gravelle warned that guidance can be mistaken for a commitment and reduce markets' attention to data.
Scenarios normally accompany the baseline; extreme uncertainty justified replacing it during the pandemic.
A July 2022 wage-price spiral scenario required much higher rates and a deep recession but did not materialize.
Inflation targeting began in 1991; deliberation summaries followed in 2023.
The five-year framework review renewed the 2 percent target on November 5, 2026, through December 31, 2031.
Extraordinary guidance was used only during the financial crisis and pandemic.
Conditionality is the message
Gravelle presented scenarios as preparation for alternative outcomes, not promises about rates.
He cautioned that publishing too many can obscure the baseline and confuse priorities.
He linked transparency to accountability, anchored inflation expectations and the credibility supporting operational independence.