Pro-rata loss sharing cuts comparable CCP tranche to one third
Bank of England modelling finds that pro-rata second skin-in-the-game at central counterparties can match a later tranche's expected loss with 17–49 percent of its size. The central illustrative estimate is 32 percent, not a binding calibration.
Earlier exposure raises expected losses
The Bank of England compares second skin-in-the-game (SSITG) at central counterparties (CCPs) after the prefunded default fund with SSITG consumed alongside it, before unfunded resources.
For a £100 million tranche, expected losses are £95,000 and £295,000 respectively.
Single-tranche events A, B and C carry probabilities of 99.9, 0.01 and 0.09 percent: no SSITG use, partial use and exhaustion.
Central pro-rata events D, E and F assign 99.5, 0.41 and 0.09 percent to equivalent outcomes, but partial use begins alongside the default fund.
Earlier resources include the defaulter's margin and fund contribution and the CCP's first skin-in-the-game.
Uniform losses within each exposed layer imply average SSITG consumption of 50 percent.
Calibration spans 17–49 percent
With Event D probabilities of 99, 99.5 and 99.7 percent, Event E probabilities are 0.91, 0.41 and 0.21 percent.
Expected losses on £100 million are £545,000, £295,000 and £195,000; matching £95,000 requires approximately 17, 32 and 49 percent of the single-tranche amount.
A tranche set at 25 percent of regulatory capital translates to roughly 4–12 percent, centrally 8 percent.
Event F stays at 0.09 percent to isolate sensitivity.
Initial margin coverage informs the scenarios but does not map directly to Event D.
Comparable losses, not equivalent resilience
The estimates measure expected-loss comparability, not full economic equivalence or a preferred design.
Fixed event probabilities and uniform layer losses limit calibration precision.
The note calls for CCP-specific stress losses, member positions and waterfall data; incentives and resilience can differ.