Cheaper job advertising raises equilibrium labor market tightness
Falling recruitment costs explain part of the long-run rise in UK vacancies, Bank of England researchers find. Real advertising expenditure per vacancy fell more than 80 percent since 2000, changing the benchmark for assessing labor market slack.
More vacancies for less money
Michal Stelmach, James Kensett and Philip Schnattinger construct a UK vacancy-cost index from recruitment advertising expenditure beginning in 1982.
Real posting costs fell around 87 percent between 2005 and 2024; broader recruitment costs fell 88 percent for senior managers over that period.
An error-correction model using 1982–2025 data links equilibrium vacancies to posting costs and productivity.
A calibrated search-and-matching model reproduces a rise in equilibrium vacancies per unemployed worker from 0.19 to 0.40 across high- and low-cost recruitment regimes.
Halving posting costs raises equilibrium tightness 2.15-fold in the baseline; including one-off training costs reduces the response to around 1.7–1.8-fold.
The denominator complicates the evidence
The cost index divides advertising expenditure by vacancies, creating a mechanical negative relationship with vacancy numbers.
Independent evidence offers partial support: UK and German cost measures correlate at 0.95 during 2000–2012 but diverge thereafter.
UK traditional advertising prices fell 37 percent during 2000–2024, against an 84 percent fall in expenditure per vacancy.
Those prices exclude online recruitment, while spending measures also capture recruiting intensity.
The authors' views do not represent Bank of England policy.
A moving benchmark for slack
The authors find that historical vacancy ratios can misstate slack because equilibrium tightness has risen.
Their latest estimates place the observed ratio below equilibrium, indicating spare capacity.
They stress that uncertainty about equilibrium unemployment also affects this assessment.